Ban Appeals

[Prada]

Hai fellas,


As the title shines , this suggestion is consist of ban appeals. Exactly , i want to feedback an ,,INVISIBLE BAN APPEALS,, . Invisible for infinitians and other taggers except Staff Team/Supporters.I think many of you know that the report section had been opened for Everyone's view , and then it has changed with the algorithm of , so only Staffers and special taggers could view and reply on it. So even tho it is not the same case , still would be nice to make visible for Staff's access.

Whatever, others already cannot reply on that thread . Plus , 50% of appeals almost always are in the wrong format. And after the creation of appeal , the thread goes to trashed , so one more suggestion that the thread includes is , to don't post the appeal untill it will get checked. Like for example ,,Applications,, untill it will be posted for public , there should be an unchek , you know what i mean ? And if the appeal is wrong it won't be posted for public or staff's or view. In brief , as the main part of thread says , i vote for invisible ban appeals , people except team are not in a great necessity to see that.

 

[Flippy]

This sugestion is great.
Since the appeal must be solved by the GM who banned the user, maybe it should stay visible only for staff team since the discussions took place there.
Its still a sensitive area and it would reduce the flaming around thee forums.
I heavily support this sugestion!
Regarding the aproval as a staff application let it be free so personal interests/disputes wont interfere. We have enough wrong reports as well so 1-2 more ban appeals wont be that much.

 

[Halfdanjal]

Well, I have to agree. We see the ban list, and we can also see if they are unbanned, we don't have to see the process of it. Nothing more to say here.

 

[Ashtaroth!]

There is also pro and cons in the suggestion made.

Pro
> The person NAME who created the thread for ban appeals (no matter what bans they got) will be much more protected & clear. i meant not all of the players know, but only fews to their mistakes, which means He/She can get a 2nd chance to get better in game after serving the sentences.
> The players who used hack in game will get unaware of getting caught hacking as those who do hacking or being 'naughty' in game will never know who's "watching" them.

Cons
< Only those who involved in the ban appeal process will know what happen which sometimes in the case of the person who are lacked in knowledge of what they've done not being able to defends themselves no matter if its wrong or right.
< So the chances of the appealing process being success got lower percentage.

Eventhough this is a good suggestion and i would totally support it !

 

[Lelouch]

if youre saying make the ban appeal completely invisible from the normal members of the forum i gotta say i DONT agree with it...
firstly normal members have to see why he was unbanned specially the reporter who reported the said player that was unbanned...
secondly...you mentioned something about wrong format ban appeals that goes straight to trash...but it doesnt users are being warned before it goes to trash cause how can the user know that its on the wrong format...some users are new and dont read much that they need to be warned before they know that its on the wrong format...


well you somewhat mentioned something about filtering it which somewhat sounds good if you mean after the filtering and that its been approved by a staff member it would be visible to the others then i can agree to it cause that way...users can be warned in the thread which only he and the staff team can see and after he corrects it then it can be viewed public this is something i can agree with...


but on making it completely invisible to normal members i have to say NO...

 

[Andromeda]

I disagree because there is no need to hide things from infinitians, if you talk about the shame of having to make a public appeal, im sorry but maybe that person shouldnt have broken the rules in first place. It's great that this part is left transparent and i wouldnt agree to change that.

 

[Dimer]

The way it is right now it's fine,the incorrect format is of no bother to us.Also ban appeals are open for this exact reason,for infinitians to see them,even if they can't write in there,it's a learning table for them.

I wouldn't consider making them visible for the Staff Members only.The things posted above are not valid reason enough I think Andromeda explained it well too.

/Closed and denied